-->
Skip to main contentFor the 14th consecutive year, we finish up the model year in ALL ABOUT CARS with a Top-10 list consisting of the vehicles we tested and reviewed t …
For the 14th consecutive year, we finish up the model year in ALL ABOUT CARS with a Top-10 list consisting of the vehicles we tested and reviewed this year; and after rating them, have concluded that they are the “best deals on wheels” in 2018. Next week, we will present our “vehicle of the year” regardless of price.
Now, just because a vehicle delivers the best bang for the buck, it doesn’t always translate into sales. In 2018, trucks were the top three-selling vehicles in the U.S., and no truck made my list this year. To make ALL ABOUT CARS’ “Car Buy of the Year” list, sales is not part of the equation. To be considered for this list, I must have test-driven the vehicle during calendar 2018, and dollar-for-value, or worth vs. cost carries the most weight, though some abstracts still apply.
Rated for this year’s competition, I test drove 54 vehicles, drove them, tested them and examined them for about a week each, using them as daily drivers around town for errands and for maneuvering; on the highway for long trips, for passing, stability and for fun; accelerating them and braking them hard on straight tracks and banked venues, auto-crosses and drag strips, and checking out what passengers and onlookers reported.
The cars tested vary from year to year. Some years we have higher-priced vehicles of great value on the list -- a low price is not always the sign of a great value. Price certainly is a factor; as is fuel economy, but the vehicle’s personality, how it fits its niche and how you feel driving it all play a part. This year, the winner was one of three finalists priced under $30,000 and eight of the 10 were under $40,000. Two cars on the list were priced in the $40,000 range.
The candidates were graded in eight categories, with vehicles earning 10 points for best possible to 1 point for worst possible. I gave only six perfect 10s in any category all year; no vehicle received less than a charitable 5 in any category, and no vehicle received more than a single category 10. My eight graded segments are: Interior; Safety; Power; Handling/Ride; Economy/Price; Looks; Niche-fitting and a Miscellaneous grouping in which I took into consideration the “feel-good” factor and other subjective intangibles
One more thing: the difference between this week’s Best Car Buy winner and next week’s “Car of the Year” champion is that this week it is all about best value for the price across all eight categories, and not necessarily the lowest amount of dollars spent. Next week’s winner is all about the car, truck or crossover and what it delivers, regardless of price – just the pure vehicle.
My 2018 Top Buys of the Year are led by two small SUV-CUVs, topped by a sporty above-badge sports-ute; and on the list were a minivan, a muscle car and a flagship sedan. Two on this list ALSO were finalists for next week’s “Car of the Year.” Prices reflect my review vehicles-as-tested.
No. 1 Hyundai Kona: Sub-Compact CUV targets urban adventurers -- $29,805
For the second year in a row, Hyundai topped my list (last year, the Hyundai Elantra came out on top). This year, Hyundai has targeted youthful “urban adventurers” with its all-new sub-compact crossover utility vehicle, the 2018 Hyundai Kona. With “urban smart armor” exterior styling, Kona has a bold and sporty demeanor packed with leading safety technology and advanced infotainment features in a compact footprint. Kona offers two engine choices and my test ride had a 2.0-liter 4-cylinder Atkinson engine that produces 147 horsepower and 132 lb.-ft. of torque and is mated to a six-speed automatic transmission. Kona was fun to drive and averaged 26.7 mpg during a week of mixed-use runs. Look for Kona next week on the CAR of the YEAR list.
No. 2 Kia Niro: Sporty hybrid CUV adds safety and tech packages -- $29,710
Niro is a Hybrid that doesn’t look like a Hybrid, packaged as a Crossover that doesn’t look or act quite like a Crossover. Upgraded for 2018 with a new plug-in model, new cosmetics, and a full suite of safety and tech enhancements. The two-tiered power system is rated at 139hp and 195 lbs.-ft of torque, and my week of interstate and in-town driving averaged 53 mpg on the highway and 44.2 mpg overall.
No. 3 Honda Accord: All new with enhanced power, styling, connectivity -- $33,322
The 2018 Accord is all-new from the ground up from its structure to powertrain. Re-engineered for weight, safety, aerodynamics and style with a crisp, sporty design, the new Accord has a longer wheelbase and also has improved connectivity and driver-assistive technology. The new 1.5-liter, 16-valve DOHC direct-injected turbo engine produces a peak of 192 horsepower and 192 lb.-ft. of torque. I averaged 33.4 mpg in tests.
No. 4 Subaru Forester: Performance, Intuitive Cabin and Safety --$30,296
Subaru Forester remains a sports utility ride for the “granola-and-fresh water” brigade. Lives up to its slogan: “SUV tough, car easy,” with the versatility of a minivan, car and small sports-ute in its abilities. Adds new cosmetics inside and out, and new driving and safety technology. My test ride’s 2.5-liter engine delivered 170 horses and 174 lbs.-ft. and averaged 28.1 mpg.
No. 5 Hyundai Elantra: Increased tech, safety and trims -- $27,865
This popular compact now looks more like a fastback, with its roofline sloped from the windshield to the rear of the car, and redesigned grille, lights, body panels and bumper emphasizing straight lines along the body. Elantra power comes from a Nu 2.0-liter MPI Atkinson Cycle DOHC 16-valve engine that puts out 147 horsepower and 132 lbs.-ft. of torque. I averaged 32.0mpg.
No. 6 Jeep Compass: Compact CUV adds upgraded materials and tech -- $34,415 The Jeep Compass is a compact crossover that on the looks of Grand Cherokee. Compass comes at you with a Premium, sculptural design, wide stance, legendary Jeep seven-slot grille and typical Jeep off-road and in-town abilities. Outfitted with a 2.4-liter Tigershark engine that produces 180hp and 175 lbs.-ft. of torque, mated to a 9-speed automatic transmission, In tests, I averaged 25.7mpg.
No. 7 Ford Mustang GT: More Pony Power, exterior and tech gains -- $45,875
The highest ticket on the list is a best-buy with a sleek new design, more advanced tech and improved performance enhancements … and a 435hp 5.0-liter V-8 that provides 420 lb-ft of torque. With a 22-inch all-digital instrument cluster, improved aerodynamics and Pony history, I averaged 18.2 mpg in lots of on-track and highway tests. A ton of performance, style, tech, muscle and nostalgia at the price. Also on next week’s list.
No. 8 Ford Explorer: Capable, confident, rugged and powerful -- $36,225
Proving that Compact SUVs aren’t the only Crossovers on the list, the 2018 Explorer gets upgraded active safety and driver assist tech systems, a new grille insert, with redesigned and smaller fog light housings, and displays response, power and handling in all ranges. Powered by a 3.5-liter Ti-VCT V-6 engine that delivers 290hp and 255 lbs-ft of torque, a week of mixed-use testing achieved an average of 23.3mpg.
No. 9 Dodge Caravan: Room for seven and priced to sell -- $33,585
The first minivan to ever make my Top-10 list, Caravan is priced at $20,000 less than the No.2-selling minivan – Dodge’s Pacifica. It fits the niche well and shows enough brawn, powered by a 3.6-liter Pentastar V-6 engine mated to a six-speed, adaptive electronic control transmission with an electronically modulated torque converter clutch. The system puts out 283 hp and 260 lbs-ft of torque. I average 26.9 mpg in tests.
No. 10 Toyota Avalon: Flagship mid-size sedan is premium and bold -- $43,412
The second highest price on this list, Toyota’s luxury sedan, the Avalon has a coupe-like profile, bold grille, discrete chrome trim, chiseled shoulder line and sculpted side sheet metal. Avalon remains unique in its segment with the choice of V6 or hybrid powertrains. The Avalon’s 3.5-liter, DOHC V-6 with Dual VVT-i produces 268 horsepower and 248 lb.-ft. of torque. I averaged 26.9mpg in tests.
Next week, we present our annual CAR of THE YEAR list… and you will see several of these great buys again.
Visit www.CarlisleEvents.com for more on the automotive hobby.
Mike Blake, former editor of KIT CAR magazine, joined Carlisle Events as senior automotive journalist in 2004. He's been a "car guy" since the 1960s and has been writing professionally for about 30 years.
 Book online or call (800) 216-1876